Home » Intellectual Incest

Intellectual Incest

One of my mentors, Dr Joe Vigil, coined that phrase many
years ago. He used it describe coaches who pass around the same information,
usually misinformation, in a small group and believe it to be gospel. They keep
reinforcing their own misinformation. You need to ask yourself as a coach where
do you get your information. Have you taken the time to go talk to a coach in
another sport and learn how they train or how they organize practice? Have you
read any technical journals in the last month? Have you read any scientific
journals in the last month? Do you do the things you do because that is the way
they have always been done? Does all your information come from the internet?
If so you might consider going beyond the internet. Do you have a mentor that
has had a variety of experiences? It is so easy to get caught up in
intellectual incest while searching for the latest and greatest, the secret or
the next big thing. I am convinced that the next big thing in coaching in general
and athletic development in particular will come from a generalist who searches
well beyond traditional fields in the coaching domain. Since August I have fifty
books, only ten of those books were directly related to sport or training, most
were well outside the field, some in cognitive neuroscience, some in communication,
some biographies. What they all had in common is that they stimulated ideas
that I think are helping to improve my coaching. I encourage you to do the
same. This is one of the goals of the GAIN Apprentorship – to challenge
people to get out of their comfort zone and search farther afield. All that
being said remember the immortal words of Gertrude Stein “the answer is there
no answer.”

Share This Post
3 Comments
  1. “the answer is there is no answer” I’m going to challenge that statement. Yeah I know what you’re thinking, who is this guy who has very few credentials to challenge such a great thinker. Well, the statement, if true in general cannot exclude itself which would also make itself untrue. It’s not possible to have an answer and no answer at the same time.
    The statement would be more believeable if it said, “the answer is, there is no one answer.” And even then that statement isn’t ALWAYS true. Just my 2 cents, take it for what you will.
    JH

    Reply
  2. Hi JH
    I think you demonstrate a problem that VErn talks about alot. Concentrating on such small things without looking at the big picture. I have to think you must be joking by putting such a comment. Vern I think you are right on and if this guy is not joking with his comment we have significant issues

    Reply
  3. Craig,
    I appreciate your thoughts. However the statement, “there are no answers” falls into the same category as the statement “there is no absolute truth.” If it is true it cannot exclude itsself and therefore cannot be true. As Vern talked about a couple posts ago he mentioned communication. Within people’s statements/questions (even mine) there are underlying assumptions. The challenge with communication is to avoid these assumptions with our statements and questions as they could be misleading. To say to me that the answer is there are no answers is demoralizing. Do new answers lead to other questions as Vern has posted? Absolutely, but those addition questions do not automatically nullify the previous answers. In some cases they do but not in all. So to tell me there are no answers in general is ridiculous. Sometimes there aren’t answers (atleast that I can find) but sometimes there are.
    Mr. Duncan, I am not joking.
    JH

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>