I am tired of hearing about red flags and dysfunctions. Why is something a red flag or a dysfunction? Watch what happens when the athlete gets up and actually moves; it is amazing how many of the red flags disappear and the supposed dysfunctions discovered in isolated artificial movements smooth out. If there is pain they will tell you. If you feel you have to look for red flags do so when the athlete is actual moving. Evaluate movements just like you train movements. Our job as coaches, therapists and ATC’s is to get the athlete moving as efficiently as possible not to segment and robotize. Chances are if there is a deficiency it will scream out at you. A truly functional movement screen will have the body move through and in postures that are similar to the postures in actual performance, executing movements that work with or against gravity. It must give some information on how the athlete uses the ground and how they reduce force and dynamically stabilize. There is no universal movement screen. I believe that you must have a screen that is specific to the movements of the sport or at the very least for categories of sports. For example a movement screen for throwing sports would have different elements than would an evaluation for a running sports. One size does not fit all. Incorporate movements like bending, extending, reaching, pulling, and pushing. This will give you information you can then translate into the training and performance environment. Don’t look for what the athlete can’t do, look for what they can do and use that as a starting point for the training progression. Beware of confirmation bias – you find what you are looking for.
Look around, get your head out of the sand and recognize that it is our job to get the athlete ready for the rigors of competition by training them to be as adaptable as possible to the demands of their sport. You don’t do that by focusing on what the athlete can’t do and fixing supposed dysfunctions through corrective exercise. All exercise should be corrective to a degree if you use proper progression. Corrective exercise and injury prevention should be a transparent part of a sound training program. I have said for years that Training = Rehab and Rehab = Training. I will end with two questions: If what is going on today in MLB, NFL & NBA is so good then why are preventable injuries off the scale? Is it because we are looking so hard at dysfunctions and prevention that we are compromising training and preparation?
BJ Maack
I like this. So tired of $$ making programs trying to do a cookie-cutter approach with all aspects of athlete development: rehab, training, PT, screening, etc. I will take your sentence one step further: “One size doesn’t fit all—it fits ONE.”
carmen@humanmotion.com
Hi Vern, I think the good practitioners have always known this and have taken bits and bites from others and applied them appropriately. Have you read Easy Strength yet? Pavel talks about this – how athletes are almost making excuses these days because their body does not “feel perfect.” In elite sport, we walk a dangerous line of performance and injury, but the good ones can strike the balance and sometimes athletes are simply unlucky and they get hurt. I like what you have to say; I always have. We cannot put the principle of individualization and the principle of specificity in a box and you have said just that! I use a multitude of assessments with my clients and base my prescription on all of the above. And this is what I teach to my college students too.
Craig Liebenson
Carmen,
Great point from Pavel. I love in Easy Strength where Pavel refers to people “scanning their carcass…” Athletes’ are kings of compensation so dysfunction should not retard performance. But, it may affect durability. Doc Rivers said it best “the most important trait of an athlete is AVAILABILITY”. A teams success is largely due to # of days lost to injury.
I think we have a lot to learn in this area. But, enhancing durability should be one of our major goals.
Craig
Tim
It’s all movement… movement, skill, performance. No one special than the other.